LONG ISLAND CITY, QUEENS
Astoria Seafood
Pick your fish from the market case, BYOB, and let the kitchen grill it Greek-style — gleeful chaos included.
Astoria Seafood is a working fish market on an industrial block that happens to run one of the most joyful dinner formats in New York: you grab a plastic bag, pick your fish and shrimp from the iced cases, hand it over, and tell the kitchen Greek-style grilled, fried, or over pasta. Minutes later it lands at a paper-covered table amid the happiest BYOB chaos in Queens.
There is nothing polished about it — fluorescent light, a weekend line out the door, retsina in plastic cups someone brought — and that is the entire charm. Three generations of a Greek family have kept the fish honest; the room does the rest.
Editor’s tip
Bring your own wine, pick a whole fish plus a bag of shrimp, and say 'grilled, lemon, oregano' — that's the move.
Also in the neighborhood
LONG ISLAND CITY, QUEENS
Casa Enrique
Michelin-starred Chiapas cooking in a quiet LIC storefront that never stopped being a neighborhood spot.
Mexican · Hidden Gem · $$$
LONG ISLAND CITY, QUEENS
Dutch Kills
A neon 'BAR' sign, hand-cut ice, and one of the city's great cocktail rooms hiding on Jackson Avenue.
Cocktails · Cocktail Bar · $$
Editorial draft — core details last reviewed October 13, 2026. Confirm practical details with the official site before you go.