Skip to content

WILLIAMSBURG, BROOKLYN

St. Anselm

The 2011 Metropolitan Avenue steakhouse where the butcher's steak still beats everything.

See current Google rating & reviews ↗
Illustration of an American table: a burger, fries and a pickleIllustration
Illustration · not a photo of this venue

A narrow brick-and-wood room with maybe eight tables and a long counter facing the grill, open since 2011 and still one of the best places in the city to eat a steak. Everything is cooked in the open, showered with salt, and the room feels like a cabin upstate that happens to be on Metropolitan Avenue.

Order the butcher's steak — every time, even over the pricier cuts — then pan-fried mashed potatoes, creamed spinach and whatever else appeals, and a chocolate pot de crème to finish. Two people should ask for the counter, where you can watch the grill work.

Editor’s tip

Arrive early for a walk-in counter seat; after 7pm on weekends it's a long wait.

Make an evening of it — beautiful stops nearby

Also in the neighborhood

Editorial draft — core details last reviewed October 14, 2026. Confirm practical details with the official site before you go.