Skip to content

Brooklyn

Carroll Gardens

Deep front gardens, a pastry case on Court Street, and pizza worth the wait on Henry.

The gardens came first, on paper. In 1846 the surveyor Richard Butt laid out these blocks with the houses set unusually far back from the street, and the brownstones that followed kept those deep front yards — fenced, planted, and in summer full of roses and tomato vines. The neighborhood takes the rest of its name from Charles Carroll of Maryland, the only Catholic signer of the Declaration of Independence, whose regiment fought nearby in the Battle of Long Island.

Italian immigrants arrived in the late nineteenth century to work the docks and the Navy Yard, and Court Street became theirs: pork stores, pastry shops, social clubs, and St. Mary Star of the Sea, where Al Capone was married. The Italian share of the neighborhood has fallen sharply since 1980, but you can still buy cannoli from a pastry shop that has been on Court Street since 1948.

Smith Street, a block east, is the other half of the story — a restaurant row of small dining rooms that has fed Brooklyn for a generation. Between the two, the side streets are some of the most beautiful in the borough: the Carroll Gardens Historic District, landmarked in 1973, is best seen slowly, on foot, in late spring.

Brownstones set behind deep, fenced front gardens

Italian pastry, pork stores and social clubs on Court Street

Smith Street's run of small dining rooms

Local notes

Carroll Gardens Historic District

Designated by the Landmarks Preservation Commission in 1973, the district takes in stretches of President and Carroll Streets between Smith and Hoyt, where the deep front gardens from the 1846 survey are at their most generous. Walk them in May or June, when the yards are in bloom.

Carroll Park

Laid out in the late 1840s and bought by the city in 1853, the park between Court and Smith Streets is named for Carroll's Maryland regiment.

Court Street, changing

Caputo's Bake Shop, the lard-bread bakery at 329 Court Street, closed in April 2026 after 124 years, according to Brooklyn Paper. Court Pastry Shop, open since 1948, carries on a few blocks north — go while you can.

Through the lens

The front gardens photograph best from the sidewalk opposite in morning light, when the stoops and iron fences throw clean shadows. Carroll Street between Smith and Hoyt is the classic frame. For Court Street, shoot storefront signage at dusk, when the pastry cases are lit.

Editorial draft — core details last reviewed October 13, 2026. Confirm practical details with the official site before you go.

Where to eat & drink