Skip to content

LOWER EAST SIDE, MANHATTAN

Attaboy

No menu, no sign: knock on the Eldridge Street door and let the bartender decide.

See current Google rating & reviews ↗
Illustration of cocktails on a bar topIllustration
Illustration · not a photo of this venue

Behind an unmarked door on Eldridge Street, in the room that was once Milk & Honey, Attaboy is run by veterans of that bar and keeps its spirit. The space is closet-sized, and you knock to come in.

There is no menu. Tell the bartender what you like — a spirit, a mood, sweet or bitter — and they build a drink around it, usually a sharp riff on a classic. Most people end up standing, and most people don't mind.

Editor’s tip

Go right after opening on a weeknight, and describe a flavor rather than naming a drink.

Make an evening of it — beautiful stops nearby

Also in the neighborhood

Editorial draft — core details last reviewed October 14, 2026. Confirm practical details with the official site before you go.