The Holiday Almanac · Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving Takeout & Pies to Pre-Order in NYC, 2026

Seventeen New York bakeries, butchers and restaurants taking Thanksgiving 2026 pre-orders, from a Peking-style turkey and a hot-from-the-oven delivery to $34 farmhouse pies, with prices, order deadlines and pickup times.

Checked on the organizers’ own pages, October 25, 2026

A whole pumpkin pie in a tart pan beside halved pumpkins and pecans — Envato Elements

Not everyone wants to spend Thanksgiving in a restaurant, or in the kitchen. These are the New York places that have posted 2026 pre-orders: whole turkeys roasted, smoked or brined for you, complete dinners for two or twenty, and the city's best pies.

We checked every one on its own ordering page on October 25, 2026, and the prices are the ones each has posted. The popular ones sell out, so mind the deadlines; most pickups are Tuesday or Wednesday, November 24 or 25.

Thanksgiving at home

Envato Elements
Envato Elements
Envato Elements

Midtown EastConfirmed for 2026

Hutong

The most original bird in town: a turkey lacquered and air-dried like Peking duck, carved with pancakes, then a second course of Má Là turkey.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Order until Wed, Nov 25 at 12pm
Cost: Whole Peking Turkey $248; Thanksgiving Deluxe $198 (serves 2–3) or $388 (serves 4–6)
Where: 731 Lexington Ave

Source: Official site ↗

Prospect Heights, BrooklynConfirmed for 2026

BKLYN Larder

A Brooklyn cheese shop's Thanksgiving: a fully roasted bird, or a brined one to cook yourself, with stuffing, gravy and a cheese board.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pickup Wed, Nov 25, 10am–8pm and Thu, Nov 26, 9am–2pm; delivery Wed 9am–noon in Brooklyn and Queens
Cost: Whole roast turkey $225 (13–15 lb, serves about 6–8); turkey roll $125; brined uncooked turkey $150; stuffing $40; gravy $30
Where: 228 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn

Cancel before Nov 3 for a refund.

Source: Official site ↗

Chelsea MarketConfirmed for 2026

Dickson's Farmstand Meats

The butcher's choice: Pennsylvania birds by size, heritage KellyBronze, a smoked turkey, or one roasted and handed over hot.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pickup Tue, Nov 24 or Wed, Nov 25 during shop hours
Cost: Fresh turkeys from $81.50 (10–12 lb) to $195.60 (24–27 lb); KellyBronze from $228.67; smoked cooked turkey $180; hot roast turkey $325
Where: Chelsea Market, 75 Ninth Ave

Changes and cancellations until Nov 1.

Source: Official site ↗

Midtown WestConfirmed for 2026

Bread & Honey

Thanksgiving delivered hot from the oven, carved if you like, for anyone between 50th and 58th Streets, from Seventh to Tenth Avenue.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Order by Sun, Nov 22, 3pm; last delivery 1pm and last pickup 3pm on Thanksgiving
Cost: Turkey Dinner $335; oven-roasted turkey $225; carving $25; tofu cutlets with vegan gravy $36; sides from $32
Where: 941 Eighth Ave

Source: Official site ↗

Upper East Side & Long Island CityConfirmed for 2026

Butterfield Market

A neighborhood market's full menu, from a whole dinner for twelve down to a $49.99 Thanksgiving for one with its own little pumpkin pie.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Order by Fri, Nov 20, 4pm; pickup Wed, Nov 25 and Thu, Nov 26 (9am–1pm)
Cost: Individual dinner $49.99; Complete for 6 $300 ($365 with a whole turkey); Complete for 12 $565; pies $28–38
Where: 1150 Madison Ave; 29-17 40th Ave, Long Island City

Thursday pickup adds $25; no Manhattan deliveries between 34th and 44th Streets on parade day.

Source: Official site ↗

Flatiron & Financial DistrictConfirmed for 2026

Eataly

An Italian Thanksgiving: turkey with porchetta stuffing and tiramisù, or a raw bird and the fixings to cook it yourself.

When: Pre-order
Hours: 48 hours' notice; pickup or delivery
Cost: Whole Turkey Meal (serves 6–8) $299; Turkey Breast Meal $149; KellyBronze turkey $17.99/lb; pies $42.90
Where: 200 Fifth Ave and 101 Liberty St

Source: Official site ↗

Astoria, QueensConfirmed for 2026

Pig Beach BBQ

A smoked turkey feast for ten to twelve from Queens' barbecue hall, packed cold with reheating instructions.

When: Pre-order
Hours: All pickups Wed, Nov 25 (closed Thanksgiving)
Cost: Full Feast (16–18 lb smoked turkey, cranberry, gravy, 2 sides and a pie; serves 10–12) $275; whole smoked turkey $125; pies $35
Where: 35-37 36th St, Queens

Source: Official site ↗

HarlemConfirmed for 2026

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Harlem

A pit-roasted turkey with the sides and pies, picked up by the Hudson in an hourly time slot.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pickup hourly, 10am–6pm, Tue, Nov 24 and Wed, Nov 25
Cost: Turkey Deluxe (serves 8–12, with 2 pies) $275; Half Turkey Deluxe (serves 3–5) $150; turkey and gravy only $180
Where: 700 W 125th St

Source: Official site ↗

HarlemConfirmed for 2026

Amy Ruth's

Soul food for ten from a Harlem institution: turkey with stuffing or a ham, with sweet potato pie and cornbread.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Order by Sun, Nov 22, 6pm (by phone, 212-280-8779)
Cost: Turkey or ham package for 10 (two sides, sweet potato pie, cornbread) $319 + tax; whole turkey or ham $169
Where: 113 W 116th St

Source: Official site ↗

A fried chicken sandwich with pickles, lettuce and sauce on a soft bun, served on a Jacob's Pickles cutting board — Courtesy of Jacob's Pickles

Upper West SideConfirmed for 2026

Jacob's Pickles & Maison Pickle

A Thanksgiving box for two, plus trays of biscuits and sides, from the Upper West Side's Southern comfort kitchens.

When: Pre-order
Hours: For Thanksgiving Day, Nov 26 (Maison Pickle: pickup only, 48 hours' notice)
Cost: Feast for Two $160 at either restaurant; trays from $55; whole pie $55
Where: 680 Columbus Ave; 2315 Broadway

Source: Official site ↗ · On LovelyNYC →

TribecaConfirmed for 2026

Bubby's

Tribeca's pie temple sells whole pies for the holiday and a complete takeout dinner for two.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pies: order by Fri, Nov 20, pickup Nov 24–25; takeout dinner Thu, Nov 26, 10am–2pm
Cost: Thanksgiving Take Out for 2 $200 (turkey and ham, six sides, biscuits and a slice of three pies)
Where: 120 Hudson St

Source: Official site ↗ · On LovelyNYC →

Gowanus, BrooklynConfirmed for 2026

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

The Brooklyn pie shop that made salty honey pie famous, with four Thanksgiving pies to pick up.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pickup Sun, Nov 22 through Thu, Nov 26 (8am–3pm on Thanksgiving)
Cost: Ten-inch pies $46: Brown Butter Pumpkin, Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan, Salty Honey or Salted Caramel Apple
Where: 439 Third Ave, Brooklyn

Local delivery has already sold out, so order for pickup.

Source: Official site ↗

Williamsburg & Park Slope, BrooklynConfirmed for 2026

Pies 'n' Thighs

Twenty years of Brooklyn pie: sweet potato, bourbon pecan, banana cream and sour cherry-pear, and a fried chicken spread for a crowd.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pickup or delivery
Cost: Whole pies $45; fried chicken and sides package (serves 15–20) $300
Where: 166 S 4th St; 244 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn

Code EARLYBIRD takes $15 off orders over $100 before Oct 31.

Source: Official site ↗

Park Slope, BrooklynConfirmed for 2026

Miolin Bakery

A Park Slope bakery's short Thanksgiving list: three pies, pumpkin bread and a cranberry-pecan loaf.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Pickup Tue, Nov 24 through Thu, Nov 26 (8–10am on Thanksgiving)
Cost: Pies $60 (apple, pumpkin or maple pecan); pumpkin bread $18; cranberry-pecan sourdough $13
Where: 422 Seventh Ave, Brooklyn

Source: Official site ↗

Hell's KitchenConfirmed for 2026

Little Pie Company

Nine pies, from sour cream apple walnut to a sugarless apple pie, plus two gluten-free ones.

When: Pre-order
Hours: Prepaid; no changes after Fri, Nov 20; open until noon on Thanksgiving
Cost: Pies $48; gluten-free key lime or blueberry-apple crumb $54; pumpkin cheesecake $52
Where: 424 W 43rd St

Source: Official site ↗

West VillageConfirmed for 2026

Kerber's Farm

Fourteen farmhouse pies, including a S'mores Moose, with gluten-free, vegan and sugar-free versions.

When: Pre-order
Hours: No changes after Nov 24; pickup in the window you choose
Cost: Most pies $34; pecan and S'mores Moose $36; gluten-free, vegan and sugar-free pies $37
Where: Bleecker St, West Village

Source: Official site ↗

Six Manhattan and Brooklyn locationsConfirmed for 2026

Dig

A whole spread for a crowd: turkey, stuffing, mash, Brussels sprouts, cornbread and apple crisp, or a vegetarian version.

When: Pre-order
Hours: The Upper West Side shop is open on Thanksgiving for pickup and delivery
Cost: Feasts for 8–10, 18–20 or 28–30 people (prices at checkout)
Where: Pine St, NoHo, Garment District, Upper West Side, Upper East Side and Williamsburg

Source: Official site ↗

Good to know

Your questions, answered

Where can I order Thanksgiving dinner to go in NYC in 2026?

Seventeen places on this page have posted 2026 pre-orders, including complete dinners from Butterfield Market (from $49.99 for one), Bubby's ($200 for two), Pig Beach ($275 for ten to twelve), Amy Ruth's ($319 for ten) and Eataly ($299 for six to eight).

Where can I buy a cooked turkey for Thanksgiving in NYC?

Hutong's Peking-style turkey ($248), BKLYN Larder's roast turkey ($225), Dickson's smoked ($180) or hot roast turkey ($325), Pig Beach's smoked turkey ($125), Dinosaur Bar-B-Que's pit-roasted packages and Bread & Honey's oven-roasted turkey ($225).

Which bakeries sell Thanksgiving pies in NYC?

Four & Twenty Blackbirds ($46), Pies 'n' Thighs ($45), Little Pie Company ($48), Kerber's Farm (from $34) and Miolin Bakery ($60) have all posted 2026 Thanksgiving pie orders, with pickup in the days before Thanksgiving.

When should I order?

Now. Deadlines run from November 1 (Dickson's changes) to November 20 (Butterfield Market, Bubby's pies, Little Pie Company) and November 22 (Amy Ruth's, Bread & Honey), and Four & Twenty Blackbirds' local delivery has already sold out.

Notes on the dates

Prices, deadlines and pickup times are as each business posted them on October 25, 2026. Several more, including Zabar's, Levain, Breads Bakery and Russ & Daughters, hadn't posted 2026 Thanksgiving orders yet; we'll add them when they do.

Plan the season

Get the Lovely Letter

A free weekly letter from LovelyNYC: the season's dates as they're announced, what's on this week, new restaurants and bars, and one lovely day in the city.